FEATURE: Asian docs quest to ease the pain of dying

End-of-life care in the region received a boost with the recent founding of Asia’s first research center for palliative care. Medical Tribune's Glenn Omanio reports how doctors are trying to change public perception on death and dying.
Many Asians who die every year of cancer and other chronic fatal diseases receive inadequate palliative care as the region grapples with the need for doctors and families to understand end-of-life care and comfort, palliative care experts say.
While some Asian nations have conducted pioneering work in Western-dominated palliative medicine, research efforts in palliative medicine remain relatively undeveloped in the region, especially when it comes to cultural differences in attitudes and beliefs towards dying, end-of-life experts told Medical Tribune.
“We need to improve care by getting basic facts right about our community. All our ideas about establishing palliative care evolved in the West. We have very little local and regional data on which to base our work,” said Dr. Cynthia Goh, senior consultant and head of the department of palliative medicine, National Cancer Centre Singapore (NCCS).
Central to the issues faced by palliative medicine in Asia is the lack of awareness among medical professionals and families about end-of-life care. “There’s a huge amount of ignorance in Singapore and Asia in general,” Goh said.
Twenty years after the first hospice opened in this small city-state of 4.5 million people, a recent survey showed that only one-third of Singaporeans have actually heard about palliative care services, Goh said, adding that the prospect is even bleaker in many parts of the region.
Perhaps, the diversity of culture and religion in Asia has something to do with why Asia lags behind its Western counterparts but experts cannot say how much of these factors really affect public perceptions because of the lack of formal studies.
Generally, death, which is often linked with bad luck, remains taboo in Asian cultures. Different religions also offer diverging concepts of death, making death and dying complicated to discuss.
“It’s hard for anyone, including physicians, to work with people who are going to die. You have to feel comfortable with yourself to recognize death as part of life,” said Dr. K. Ranga Rama Krishnan, executive vice dean of the Duke-NUS Graduate Medical School, Singapore.
Doctors are reluctant to discuss death while most terminally ill patients seem to not fully grasp the severity of their disease or are unwilling to admit that they are dying.
In a small study of seriously ill cancer patients published recently, Swedish researchers found that most doctors did not explicitly discuss death and dying with their patients. [BMC Palliat Care 2008 Feb 28;7(1):2]
“One of the reasons why we can’t respond to our patients is that we are afraid of our own emotions. We need to teach doctors to be comfortable with their own emotions and how to communicate well with patients,” Goh said.
Across countries and cultures, the “fear of the unknown” and ignorance of what the dying process involves makes suffering worse, with many patients fearing the pain associated with chronic illnesses.
“One of the first things that we do in palliative care is to reassure patients that dying need not be painful. We tell them that we can take away some of their pain,” Goh said.
However, she lamented that despite the discovery of powerful painkillers, national laws make it hard for pharmacists to stock morphine while doctors lack training to administer the right dosages and patients’ fear addiction to drugs.
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), more than 4.8 million dying patients who suffer from moderate to severe pain caused by cancer do not have access to palliative care services.
Millions more with other debilitating illnesses need palliative care, especially in less developed countries where a high proportion of patients are diagnosed in advanced stages of their illnesses when treatment is no longer effective.
In Asia, more than 600 institutions offer palliative care services, mostly through hospice care. However, they vary greatly in the level of service provided because of diversity in population, religion and uneven economic development.
Countries like Singapore, Hong Kong, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan have fairly well established palliative care services while such services are under development in Malaysia, the Philippines, Indonesia and India. Most Asian countries are just starting to offer this kind of service.
“Palliative care is not a wholly medical [field]. That’s why doctors do not take it as a specialty, thinking this is not for them but for volunteers and social workers. We lack doctors with specializations in palliative medicine,” Goh said.
In response, the Duke University School of Medicine and the National University of Singapore recently established Asia’s first research center for palliative care. Called the Lien Centre for Palliative Care, it will examine the clinical, social and cultural aspects of palliative care in Asia.
The center, which will be funded through a S$7.5 million dollar donation and matching funds from the Singaporean government, is housed at NCCS, the first cancer center in Southeast Asia to establish a department of palliative medicine.
“This is a dream come true for the palliative care community,” said Goh, who will be the center’s first director. “For the first time, real resources have been set aside for [palliative medicine] research and education.”
A relatively new medical specialization with a history of about 40 years, palliative medicine has only recently been granted “subspecialty” status in Singapore by the Singapore Academy of Medicine and the Specialists Accreditation Board. Subspecialty training in palliative medicine only officially started in May 2007, Goh said.
“We hope to address pressing quality of life and death issues, and sharpen the focus of resources and efforts towards the enhancement of human dignity and quality of life in the end-of-life experience,” said Krishnan, who is also chairman, department of psychiatry and behavioral sciences, Duke University Medical Center, USA.
The new center counts among its education programs a diploma course in palliative medicine developed by the NCCS and the Asia-Pacific Hospice Palliative Care Network, which is aimed at ensuring a pipeline of young doctors in the region.
“Singapore is aging very fast and 2030 is the crunch. It is quite worrying for the government to plan how to take care of its people who will be old and dying by then,”
Goh said.
For now, the center is working double-time to change public perception to regard death as a natural process rather than a failure of the medical system.
“When you are young, death is always troublesome but as you get older, you come to terms with what it means to live and die,” Krishnan said. “If you look at death as inevitable at some point, then the attitude changes somewhat.”




























